The Emerging Market Growth Engine

High technology communications may represent an emerging growth sector for Guam.

In emerging markets, slow growth in the advanced economies has shut down a traditional development path export led growth. As a result, emerging markets have had to rely once again on domestic demand.

As growth in Europe, Asia and emerging markets is mostly not encouraging, the United States is increasingly becoming the main engine of global economic growth.

It has become apparent, however, that emerging market enthusiasts underestimated at least two critical factors. First, emerging economies motivation to transform their growth models was weaker than expected.

This endogenous response to rapid productivity growth was a key factor contributing to the savings glut. Old development verities that savings drive growth had to be re assessed, because, to some extent, emerging market growth drove savings.

On balance, then, the multispeed growth patterns of the past decade are likely to continue. Even as the developed economies experience an extended period of below trend growth, the emerging economies will remain an important growth engine.

Innovative strategies are needed to combine the benefits of existing technologies along with the potential growth enabled from new emerging technologies.

Well, here population growth comes in because there among emerging economies we already have two to three children per woman, family planning is widely used, and population growth is coming to an end.

Cheap external finance, plentiful capital inflows, and commodity booms helped hide many such shortcomings and fueled 15 years of emerging market growth.

China s 4 trillion stimulus package, unveiled in November 2008, restored confidence in global commodity markets. Led by strong Chinese growth, emerging markets stabilized.

Once they developed the basic institutions needed for a market economy and learned how to avoid serious macroeconomic policy mistakes, emerging countries started benefiting from catch up growth. Those with very high investment rates, mostly in East Asia, grew faster than those with lower investment rates but, overall, catch up growth probably has been adding 2 4 percentage points to many emerging and developing countries annual growth rates.

Other established investors such as Singapore and emerging ones such as Malaysia, South Africa and Turkey are expected to add to this OFDI growth.

Now that nirvana is over, where will growth come from? To answer that question, it helps to note, as Harvard University s Ricardo Hausmann has done recently, that some of the emerging economies recent growth was illusory.

Emerging market economies delivered solid growth during the 2000 s, and even survived the global financial crisis without a growth collapse. But the specter of rising corruption is compromising the legitimacy of their economic gains and eroding support for further reforms needed to sustain their growth momentum.

Indeed, as the effects of stimulus programs wear off, new weaknesses are emerging, such as persistent inflation in India and credit misallocation in China. Given this, the notion that emerging economies will recapture the growth levels of the bubble years seems farfetched.

Besides, on closer inspection, the emerging market explanation, though convenient, is not quite as compelling as it might seem. Emerging economies are growing much faster than the advanced countries, which neoclassical growth models suggest should push global interest rates up, not down.

Many now believe that the recent broad based growth slowdown in emerging economies is not cyclical, but a reflection of underlying structural flaws. That interpretation contradicts those (including me) who, not long ago, were anticipating a switchover in the engines of the global economy, with autonomous sources of growth in emerging and developing economies compensating for the drag of struggling advanced economies.

China s dramatic manufacturing growth reflected low wages up to now. But as real wages in China and other emerging economies grow, incentives for trade will decline.

In the emerging world, however, the mismatch between growth expectations and actual potential has often become a serious issue that demand side stimulus and endless debt accumulation cannot cure. Rather, governments should stop basing their legitimacy on inflated growth prospects.

Germany, which exports a large volume of investment goods, benefited more than other eurozone member countries from the investment boom in China and other emerging economies. But emerging economy growth is now slowing considerably, including in China, where demand is shifting from investment toward consumption.

The key questions now are whether global economic growth is self sustaining without QE, whether emerging markets output will continue to rise strongly, albeit at a slower pace, and whether current global financial reform efforts will be sufficient to prevent another crisis in emerging markets.

ITHACA With 2012 underway, it is worth reflecting on how a decade of strong economic growth in emerging markets led to last year s resounding political transformations. From the dramatic events in the Middle East, to the groundswell of support for the anti corruption crusader Anna Hazare in India, leaders in emerging markets are getting a clear message from the streets that growth is not everything.

Because investors saw the potential for return at a time of slowing economic growth, and so they created financial products and financial innovation tailored to the emerging markets.

Because investors saw the potential for return at a time of slowing economic growth, and so they created financial products and financial innovation tailored to the emerging markets.

Meanwhile, growth in Germany and the eurozone core may further accelerate given the strength of emerging markets, which may show even greater resilience, underpinning more rapid global expansion.

After emerging from the crisis, indicators show a sustained growth in the economy, and a surplus in the fiscal external accounts, together with a recovery in national reserves.

By contrast, many emerging economies, highly dependent on commodity export earnings, have been stressed by the commodity price reset, sluggish growth in developed economies, and slower growth in China. Capital flight would materially add to their plight in some cases disastrously so.

SEOUL Emerging economies are facing significant uncertainty and serious downside risks. One major source of instability is the looming reversal of the US Federal Reserve s expansionary monetary policy the prospect of which is generating volatility in global financial markets and threatening to disrupt emerging economy growth.

Many emerging economies achieved rapid growth for years even decades enabling billions of people to escape extreme poverty and reducing the wealth gap between developed and developing countries. But that growth has lately slowed substantially, leading many to question whether economists spoke too soon when we labeled them the new engines of global economic growth.

Reinvigorated by two decades of rapid economic growth and a broad based opening to the outside world, Vietnam is now an emerging player in regional economic and security affairs. Indeed, in recent months the country has played a pivotal role in helping to establish Asia s emerging security order.

A combination of negligible (or even negative) growth in Europe and a significant growth slowdown in the United States has now created that loss, undermining emerging economies exports. Europe is a major export destination for many developing countries, and is China s largest foreign market.

The economic slowdown in the US, the eurozone, and China already implies a massive drag on growth in other emerging markets, owing to their trade and financial links with the US and the European Union (that is, no decoupling has occurred). At the same time, the lack of structural reforms in emerging markets, together with their move towards greater state capitalism, is hampering growth and will reduce their resiliency.

Among them, the total import and export volume of emerging services was 1,138.39 billion yuan, with an increase of 20.9 , which was 10.4 percentage points higher than the overall growth rate of import and export of services, and the proportion of promotion for emerging services increased by nearly 3 percentage points.

Nowhere is this more apparent than in analyses of emerging economies prospects. In the last few months, enthusiasm about these countries post 2008 economic resilience and growth potential has given way to bleak forecasts, with economists like Ricardo Hausmann declaring that the emerging market party is coming to an end.

JOHANNESBURG Nowadays, Africa s economic potential and the business opportunities that go with it is widely acknowledged. Poverty and unemployment are still more widespread than in other emerging markets, but accelerating growth since 2000 has made Africa the world s second fastest growing region (after emerging Asia and equal to the Middle East).

SEOUL Emerging Asian countries should be proud of their economic resilience. Despite a global economy plagued by weak growth, persistently high unemployment, and heavy debt loads, the region s emerging and developing economies grew at an average annual rate of 6.8 from 2000 2010, propping up global output and buttressing recovery efforts.

Other emerging markets growth prospects are even worse not least because of low commodity prices. As a result, these countries can expect lower capital inflows, again making for weak local currencies.

Given all this, the most critical policy question in emerging markets today is how to respond to inflows that will inevitably drive up their exchange rates and threaten export led growth.

The only chance of improvement is to decouple economic growth from energy consumption and emissions. This must happen in the emerging countries, and even more urgently in the old industrial economies.

In fact, if you compare India with the average developing country, even before the more recent period of acceleration of Indian growth now India is growing between eight and nine percent even before this period, India was ranked fourth in terms of economic growth among emerging economies.

BERKELEY The recent G 20 meeting of finance ministers in Saint Petersburg confirmed that the debate between growth and austerity is over at least for now. With protracted recession in Europe and slowdowns in emerging markets, concern about budget deficits has given way to apprehension about growth.

But emerging markets do not deserve the doom and gloom treatment they are getting these days. The real lesson from the collapse of the emerging market hype is the need to pay closer attention to growth fundamentals and to recognize the diversity of circumstances among a group of economies needlessly lumped together.

Not surprisingly, China skeptics are putting a different spin on the latest growth numbers. Fears of a shadow bank induced credit bubble now top the worry list, reinforcing longstanding concerns that China may succumb to the dreaded middle income trap a sustained growth slowdown that has ensnared most high growth emerging economies at the juncture that China has now reached.

Emerging issues